Homepage
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating
December Flavor
Cookies for Santa 🎄
Christmas is coming early — and everyone is welcome to celebrate!
Our December flavor is Cookies for Santa. It’s sweet cream ice cream mixed with three of our holiday cookie swap favorites: gingerbread, brown butter sugar cookies, and classic chocolate chip. Each pint is topped with a hand decorated gingerbread man.
It’s a Betty Jo’s take on milk and cookies, and full of holiday cheer!
Signup for text notifications!Two Cone Heads With a Dream
Despite being born years apart, in different states, to different parents, co-founders Erin Forden and Maddie Nehlen have always shared a singular vision: Homemade small batch ice cream inspired by classic pastries and nostalgic treats.