Homepage
Main content starts here, tab to start navigating
October Flavor
Yes! Apple Pie
Potentially the most iconic fall pie finally gets the Betty Jo's treatment. To make it even better, we've partnered with Yes! Apples to source the perfect varietal, grown right here in NY!
Yes! Apple Pie is brown sugar ice cream mixed with apple pie compote and crust, topped with more compote, and a perfectly golden pie topper.
It's à la mode, elevated.
Signup for text notifications!Two Cone Heads With a Dream
Despite being born years apart, in different states, to different parents, co-founders Erin Forden and Maddie Nehlen have always shared a singular vision: Homemade small batch ice cream inspired by classic pastries and nostalgic treats.