About Us
Our Story
Betty Jo's began as a dream for the perfect pastry-inspired ice cream. Maddie and Erin first began making ice cream out of their apartments in May of 2024 but quickly needed to expand after the Sweet Cherry Pie flavor took off online. They are now producing their monthly pints out of a kitchen space in Brooklyn and are growing to meet the ever increasing demand!
How To Order
Betty Jo's is currently producing one flavor a month, with a few different pickup dates available for each month. Since we are a small operation and do not yet have a brick-and-mortar to operate out of, these pickup days are strict and we are not yet able to accommodate one-off pickups, please keep that in mind while you order!
We announce each flavor one day before the store front opens, and about 2 weeks before the pickup dates. You can find our storefront sign-up for text notifications so you never miss a drop!
We are currently only operating in New York, to those who are able to pick up in Brooklyn or Manhattan. We do not do delivery or shipping. We hope to expand to be able to serve more locations as we grow.
Visit our StorePast Flavors
-
Birthday Cake - June 2025
-
Lemon Blueberry Tart - May 2025
-
Strawberry Rhubarb Pie - April 2025
-
Black Forest Cake - March 2025
-
Cinnamon Hot Chocolate - Feb 2025
-
Lemon Meringue Pie - January 2025
-
Peppermint Bark - December 2024
-
Apple & Pear Crisp - November 2024
-
It's Banana, Pudding! - October 2024
-
Sour Cream Caramel Coffee Cake - September 2024
-
Sweet Cherry Pie - July & August 2024
-
Coney Island Queens - June 2024